UBS Seeks to Overturn $95 Million FINRA Award Over Tesla Shorting Strategy

Posted on June 5th, 2025 at 10:54 AM
UBS Seeks to Overturn $95 Million FINRA Award Over Tesla Shorting Strategy

From the desk of Jim Eccleston at Eccleston Law

UBS Wealth Management USA has filed a petition in federal court to vacate a nearly $95 million FINRA arbitration award, arguing the decision overstepped legal bounds and imposed punitive damages that defy Iowa law, as reported by AdvisorHub.

The case stems from allegedly unsuitable investment advice provided by UBS veteran Andrew Burish. According to the arbitration award issued in February, Burish encouraged a wealthy family to short Tesla stock during 2019 and 2020—an aggressive, high-risk strategy. AdvisorHub reports that the panel found that Burish continued recommending the strategy even as the investors faced significant losses. As a result, the arbitrators ordered UBS to pay $92.2 million in total, with Burish personally liable for nearly $3.1 million.

UBS claims the award exceeds the authority granted to the panel under the Federal Arbitration Act. The firm argues that the nearly $70 million in punitive damages is grossly disproportionate and inconsistent with Iowa’s public policy, especially since the investors had only sought $36 million in total damages. According to AdvisorHub, UBS asserts that a punitive award matching the $23 million in compensatory damages would be more appropriate. Alternatively, the firm asks the court to vacate the entire award.

While UBS presses its case in court, legal experts note that efforts to overturn arbitration awards face a high bar. According to AdvisorHub, courts generally show strong deference to FINRA panels and rarely finds punitive damages excessive unless they far surpass compensatory amounts.

 

Eccleston Law LLC represents investors and financial advisors nationwide in securities, employment, transition, regulatory, and disciplinary matters.

Tags: eccleston, eccleston law, finra

Return to Archive

TESTIMONIALS

Previous
Next

You are the best attorneys in the country.

CC

LATEST NEWS AND ARTICLES

February 12, 2026
CFTC Signals New Rulemaking for Prediction Markets and Crypto Oversight

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) plans to develop new regulations governing the growing prediction markets industry, Chairman Michael Selig announced, signaling a shift in regulatory strategy.

February 11, 2026
Ameriprise Advisor Phishing Incident Potentially Exposes Client Data

A phishing incident involving an Ameriprise Financial advisor potentially exposed the personal information of hundreds of clients, according to a disclosure posted by the Maine Attorney General’s office.

February 10, 2026
Merrill Lynch Expands Client Disclosures on Crypto and AI Risks

Merrill Lynch updated its required client disclosure brochure to address, for the first time, the evolving risks tied to cryptocurrency-linked investments and the firm’s expanding use of Artificial Intelligence tools.