Supreme Court Limits SEC's Use of In-House Tribunals in Securities Fraud Cases

Posted on August 29th, 2024 at 2:01 PM
Supreme Court Limits SEC's Use of In-House Tribunals in Securities Fraud Cases

From the desk of Jim Eccleston at Eccleston Law

As reported by InvestmentNews, the Supreme Court ruled in SEC v. Jarkesy that the SEC must bring actions seeking civil penalties for securities fraud in a court of law, where defendants are entitled to a trial by jury. This 6-3 decision curtails the SEC’s use of in-house tribunals led by Administrative Law Judges (ALJs) to adjudicate fraud actions, aligning with a broader trend to limit the administrative state.

Though the SEC had already shifted its approach, limiting administrative proceedings to settled cases and bringing litigated cases to federal court, InvestmentNews reports that this decision firmly establishes the requirement for jury trials in fraud cases. The Court’s analysis indicates that Jarkesy may signal similar changes for other federal agencies seeking civil penalties through internal proceedings.

The Court concluded that civil penalties designed to punish and deter, rather than compensate, must be enforced in courts of law, implicating the Seventh Amendment right to a jury trial.

This analysis suggests that enforcement actions by any federal agency, aiming to punish and deter, must be tried in federal courts.

Following the Jarkesy ruling, the SEC will likely avoid using ALJs for securities fraud matters, handling cases in federal court instead. According to InvestmentNews, this decision may impact approximately 200 open administrative proceedings and force the SEC to reconsider its approach to enforcement actions.

 

Eccleston Law LLC represents investors and financial advisors nationwide in securities, employment, transition, regulatory, and disciplinary matters.

Tags: eccleston, eccleston law, sec

Return to Archive

TESTIMONIALS

Previous
Next

This was the best of all possible outcomes and I cannot thank you and the team enough.

Michael S.

LATEST NEWS AND ARTICLES

October 15, 2025
SEC Accuses Florida Insurance Agent of $52 Million Unregistered Securities Scheme

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has filed a complaint against Florida insurance agent Charles D. Oliver, alleging he illegally sold about $52 million in unregistered oil and gas securities to roughly 50 retail investors, including retired seniors.

October 14, 2025
Morgan Stanley's Termination of Financial Advisor Highlights Scrutiny Over U-5 Filings

Morgan Stanley recently terminated a 25-year industry veteran in Miami, underscoring the heightened scrutiny surrounding U-5 filings and the challenges that accompany them.

October 13, 2025
Morgan Stanley Cuts Advisor Deferrals in 2026 Compensation Plan, Boosting Advisor Payouts

Morgan Stanley Wealth Management announced a significant change to its 2026 compensation plan, cutting advisor deferral rates by half while keeping total pay and grid structures largely unchanged.