Report: Schwab’s Cash Strategy Costs Itself and Investors Millions

Posted on August 25th, 2021 at 2:18 PM
Report: Schwab’s Cash Strategy Costs Itself and Investors Millions

From the Desk of Jim Eccleston at Eccleston Law:

According to the latest Robo Report by Backend Benchmarking, Charles Schwab’s high cash allocation in its robo advice feature, Intelligent Portfolios, may end up costing million for investors and the firm itself. Schwab Intelligent Portfolios, which is the firms automated investment allocation platform, has “carried around a 10% cash allocation” since its inception in 2015, according to the Backend Benchmarking report. The report alleges that “high cash allocations” have cost investors nearly $1.13 billion in earning in comparison with a fixed income portfolio. The report further concludes that including a 30-basis point management fee on that allocation would have enabled investors to collect an additional $531 million in earnings and increased Schwab’s revenue by nearly $369 million. 

Other reviews from Investopedia, Betterment and The New York Times, have criticized Schwab Intelligent Portfolios due to the high allocation towards cash. “Clients would have been significantly better off had Schwab charged a straightforward and transparent management fee instead of deciding to earn revenue through high cash allocations”, the report explained. Further, Backend Benchmarking determined that Schwab earned $185 million in revenue from cash allocated out of Intelligent Portfolios. However, if Intelligent Portfolios had rather opted to invest that portion in a fixed income allocation, Schwab would have earned $554 million over a six-year duration from its 30-basis point fee, according to the report. In response to a recent Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) investigation, Schwab set aside $200 million and announced that the investigation was related to the firm’s robo platform. 

Tags: eccleston, eccleston law, charles schwab, loss

Return to Archive

TESTIMONIALS

Previous
Next

I want to extend a tremendous thank you for your dedication, professionalism, hard work and patient demeanor through this challenging time. It was enjoyable interacting with everyone on your team, this certainly helped while dealing with the situation and working towards resolution.

Dan M.

LATEST NEWS AND ARTICLES

January 24, 2025
Fidelity to Shift Independent Advisor Cash to Lower-Yielding FCash Amount in 2025

Fidelity Investments plans to redirect cash balances in non-retirement brokerage accounts managed by independent financial advisors to its in-house sweep account, FCash, starting in 2025.

January 23, 2025
Barred Advisor Continues Pattern of Settlements at Western International Securities

Chris Kennedy, a barred advisor formerly associated with Western International Securities, has agreed to a $2.1 million settlement with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) over allegations of high-volume trading, or churning, in client accounts.

January 22, 2025
FINRA to Revise Outside Business Activities Rules

The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) is seeking to overhaul its rules on outside business activities (OBA) and private securities transactions.