FINRA Sanctions Former Advisor for Unsuitable Variable Annuity Exchanges

Posted on June 17th, 2025 at 11:40 AM
FINRA Sanctions Former Advisor for Unsuitable Variable Annuity Exchanges

From the desk of James Eccleston at Eccleston Law

The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) has fined and suspended former broker Thomas Vigil for making unsuitable variable annuity recommendations that resulted in customers paying higher fees.

According to a FINRA Acceptance, Waiver and Consent (AWC), from June 2019 to February 2020, Vigil recommended 10 unsuitable L-share variable annuity exchanges to nine customers and two unsuitable variable annuity purchases to two others. Those recommendations lacked a reasonable basis and led customers to incur increased costs.

As a result, FINRA imposed a 12-month suspension, a $10,000 fine, and ordered Vigil to pay $25,436 in restitution plus interest.

Variable annuities offer various contract features and optional riders. L-share annuities, in particular, carry higher fees in exchange for shorter surrender periods, making them potentially unsuitable when paired with long-term riders like a Guaranteed Minimum Withdrawal Benefit (GMWB) rider. According to ThinkAdvisor, GMWB riders typically require the customer to hold the annuity for at least five years without withdrawals to realize its full benefit.

In this case, Vigil recommended customers replace their existing annuities with L-share contracts carrying four-year surrender periods, combined with GMWB riders guaranteeing at least 10 years of 6 percent annual step-ups — a mismatch of product design and intended use.

Vigil failed to perform or document any suitability assessment for these transactions. He also neglected to conduct a comparative analysis of the costs, fees, and benefits between the surrendered and replacement annuities. Documentation falsely claimed the replacements would reduce fees, though they actually increased customer expenses by 50 basis points.

 

Eccleston Law LLC represents investors and financial advisors nationwide in securities, employment, transition, regulatory, and disciplinary matters.

Tags: eccleston, eccleston law, finra

Return to Archive

TESTIMONIALS

Previous
Next

Jim, Stephany and the whole team were a God send.  We felt like we were put into a situation where we had no advocate. Jim’s team came in with a strong, well laid out strategy on how to get our story heard. Where our outside compliance company had no ability to help, our Broker Dealer was impenitent, and the regulators were aggressive pursuing vague rules, Jim came like a barricade against an assault we did not understand. Though you pay member dues to be affiliated with FINRA and a B/D, you have no voice. The only thing that is truly heard in this un-level playing field is a bulldog’s bark like Jim’s. I would encourage anyone to call Jim and his team to find a real ally in the tough and complicated world of securities regulation. They are truly the best.

Greg P.

LATEST NEWS AND ARTICLES

October 10, 2025
Former Two Sigma Quant Researcher Faces Fraud Charges Over Manipulated Models

Federal prosecutors and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) have filed parallel actions against Jian Wu, a former quantitative researcher at Two Sigma Investments, alleging he secretly manipulated algorithmic trading models to boost his own compensation by millions of dollars.

October 9, 2025
Former Merrill Lynch Advisors Fight Allegations of Corporate Raid

A dozen former Merrill Lynch advisors who launched their own firm, OpenArc Corporate Advisory, in Atlanta are pushing back against accusations that they orchestrated a “pre-meditated corporate raid.”

October 8, 2025
Northern Trust Sues Former Advisor for Alleged Fraud and Breach of Fiduciary Duty

According to ThinkAdvisor, Northern Trust Company has filed suit against former wealth management relationship advisor Christopher Walters, alleging that he engaged in “blatant fraud” and breached his fiduciary duty to both the firm and a longtime client.