Financial Advisor Sentenced to 8 Years for Defrauding Amish Investors

Posted on February 2nd, 2024 at 2:18 PM
Financial Advisor Sentenced to 8 Years for Defrauding Amish Investors

From the desk of Jim Eccleston at Eccleston Law 

Earl D. Miller, convicted in 2022 for defrauding Amish and Mennonite investors through his real estate investment firm, "5 Star," has been sentenced to over eight years in prison. Miller, 44, raised more than $4.3 million from approximately 70 investors, the majority being Amish and Mennonite individuals with limited investment experience.

As reported by FinancialAdvisor.com, the scheme involved fraudulent representations about investing in specific real estate projects. Miller diverted investor funds for other purposes, such as paying interest to other investors, undisclosed entities, a spiritual advisor, and a pontoon boat. The sentencing includes 97 months in prison, one year of supervised release, and restitution of $2.3 million.

Despite promising not to charge for managing investors' money and claiming investments in green energy, Miller misappropriated $1 million to settle a debt with a former business partner. The SEC had previously won a judgment against Miller in 2019, ordering him to pay over $5.2 million for defrauding investors. Although unrelated to the criminal conviction, Miller filed for bankruptcy in 2016 for 11 entities linked to 5 Star. In 2018, a Chapter 11 trustee negotiated a repayment agreement of $600,000, of which Miller had paid only $36,000 by April 2021.

 

Eccleston Law LLC represents investors and financial advisors nationwide in securities, employment, transition, regulatory, and disciplinary matters.

Tags: eccleston, eccleston law

Return to Archive

TESTIMONIALS

Previous
Next

Hiring Eccleston Law has been one of the best career decisions I have made and this "investment" to maintain my sterling regulatory record has been returned many times over.  If you are in a situation where you've been unfairly accused, don't hesitate to talk with Eccleston Law. They are the best.

Thomas C.

LATEST NEWS AND ARTICLES

February 24, 2026
Merrill Lynch Highlights AI Risks as FINRA Urges Greater Oversight of Emerging Technology

Merrill Lynch has warned that the expanded use of artificial intelligence and machine learning introduces material operational, compliance, and cybersecurity risks for advisory firms.

February 23, 2026
Drive Planning Founder Pleads Guilty to $380 Million Ponzi Scheme

Todd Burkhalter, founder and chief executive officer of Drive Planning LLC, has pleaded guilty to wire fraud after admitting he orchestrated a $380 million Ponzi scheme that defrauded more than 2,000 investors.

February 20, 2026
Edward Jones Expands Equity-Style Awards to Thousands More Advisors

Edward D. Jones & Co. has expanded eligibility for its “profits interest” award, extending the equity-style incentive to thousands more advisors, according to a Securities and Exchange Commission filing reviewed by AdvisorHub.