Eccleston Law: For Investors. For Advisors
About
Who We Are
Testimonials
Disclaimers
Attorneys
For Advisors
Broker Transition
Transition Negotiations
Employment Matters
State Registration Problems & Discipline
FINRA Matters
Promissory Note Matters
Team/Parnership Disputes
CFP Board Matters
FINRA Enforcement Matters
State Registration Problems & Discipline
Transition Negotiations
Broker Litigation & Arbitration
Employment Matters
Regulatory Matters
Strategic Consulting
Whistleblower Law
Promissory Note Matters
Compliance Protection
Lawyer Referral Network
Expungement of CRD/BrokerCheck Disclosures
For Investors
Securities Fraud
Breach of Fiduciary Duty
Negligent Investment Management
Unauthorized Trading
Lawyer Referral Network
News & Articles
News
Articles
Financial Counsel Blog
Videos
Newsletter Signup
Contact
Site Menu
About
Who We Are
Testimonials
Disclaimers
Attorneys
For Advisors
For Advisors: Overview
Broker Transition
Broker Transition Overview
Transition Negotiations
Employment Matters
State Registration Problems & Discipline
FINRA Matters
Promissory Note Matters
Team/Parnership Disputes
CFP Board Matters
FINRA Enforcement Matters
State Registration Problems & Discipline
Transition Negotiations
Broker Litigation & Arbitration
Employment Matters
Regulatory Matters
Strategic Consulting
Whistleblower Law
Promissory Note Matters
Compliance Protection
Lawyer Referral Network
Expungement of CRD/BrokerCheck Disclosures
For Investors
For Investors: Overview
Securities Fraud
Breach of Fiduciary Duty
Negligent Investment Management
Unauthorized Trading
Lawyer Referral Network
News & Articles
News
Articles
Financial Counsel Blog
Videos
Newsletter Signup
Contact

Clarifications to New Suitability and Know Your Customer Rules Underscore Their Importance

Posted on September 7th, 2012 at 10:00 AM
  1. Overview:  On July 9, 2012 new FINRA Rule 2090 and FINRA Rule 2111 will take effect.  The goal of FINRA (the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority) is to “strengthen, streamline and clarify” those very important investor protection rules.  Indeed, that goal is apparent in reviewing FINRA Regulatory Notices 11-25 and 12-25, which elaborate on those new rules. 
  2. Regulatory Notice 12-25 contains an informative answer to the question of what constitutes “reasonable diligence” in attempting to obtain the customer-specific information required by new Rule 2090, the “Know Your Customer” rule.  The rule requires financial services firms (and their advisers) to “use reasonable diligence, in regard to the opening and maintenance of every account, to know (and retain) the essential facts concerning every customer and concerning the authority of each person acting on behalf of such customer.”  And an important aspect of new Rule 2090 is its emphasis on requiring Know Your Customer information not just at the time that the account was opened, but also throughout the life of the account relationship with the customer, so that the account may be effectively serviced and supervised. 
  3. What is reasonable due diligence?  FINRA answers that what is reasonable depends upon the facts and circumstances, and that absent any “red flags” indicating that the customer information is inaccurate or that the customer is unclear about the information, an adviser generally will be able to rely on that information, for example, in making investment recommendations. 
  4. However, FINRA states that an adviser “may not be able to rely exclusively on a customer’s responses” in situations such as the following:
  • The adviser “poses questions that are confusing or misleading to a degree that the information-gathering process is tainted”;
  • The customer “exhibits clear signs of diminished capacity”; or
  • Other “red flags” exist indicating that the customer information may be inaccurate.
  1. The significance of securing and updating accurate customer profile information cannot be understated.  For example, in Regulatory Notice11-25, FINRA discusses a customer’s liquidity needs, time horizon and risk tolerance for investments as being important considerations for the suitability requirements contained in new Rule 2111, the “Suitability” rule.
  2. Second, both Regulatory Notices 11-25 and 12-25 contain a host of helpful guidance with respect to new Rule 2111.  One thought-provoking commentary in Regulatory Notice 11-25 relates to the juxtaposition of risk tolerance, on the one hand, with time horizon, on the other hand.  For example, while one may assume that an investor with a long term time horizon is suitable for riskier investments, FINRA states that such an assumption may be wrong.  As FINRA states, “Some customers with long time horizons may not desire to take on such risk and others, because of considerations outside their time horizons, are unable to do so.”
  3. Another important aspect relates to the fact that the new suitability rule explicitly applies to recommended investment strategies involving a security or securities.  FINRA states in Regulatory Notice 11-02 that the term “strategy” is to be interpreted broadly, and that the rule is triggered when a firm or adviser recommends a security or a strategy regardless of whether the recommendation results in a transaction. 
  4. Most critical, FINRA states that “the term ‘strategy’ would capture a broker’s explicit recommendation to hold a security or securities.”  FINRA explains that it is reasonable to hold firms and their advisers responsible for “hold recommendations” because customers may rely on them for their expertise.  Such hold recommendations, of course, frequently were made preceding and during the market downturn in 2008, causing investors to lose substantial sums, for which securities arbitration may be an option for recovery.
  5. As part of its commentary as to what constitutes an “investment strategy”, FINRA states in Regulatory Notice 12-25 that a mere recommendation broadly to invest in equities, or in fixed income securities, would not qualify.  On the other hand, the new suitability rule would apply to investment strategies such as:
  • Investing in dividend paying equities;
  • Investing in particular market sectors;
  • Day trading;
  • Using home equity to purchase investments; and
  • Using margin loans to purchase investments.
  1. Indeed, those latter two investment strategies should be weighed against FINRA’s new section to the suitability rule entitled Customer’s Financial Ability.  The rule reads: “Rule 2111 prohibits a member or associated person from recommending a transaction or investment strategy involving a security or securities or the continuing purchase of a security or securities or use of an investment strategy involving a security or securities unless the member or associated person has a reasonable basis to believe that the customer has the financial ability to meet such a commitment” (emphasis added).  The new rule thus envisions situations in which an investment recommendation is unsuitable for an investor because he or she cannot afford to lose his or her principal.  Thus, the use of home equity, as well as margin, may be a “red flag” that the customer does not have the financial ability to engage in a particular investment transaction or investment strategy.
  2. In conclusion, new FINRA Rule 2090 related to knowing your customer and new FINRA Rule 2111 related to suitability will provide additional protections to investors.  That’s good news investors!

Tags:

Share

Return to Archive

Latest Articles
Texas Advisor, Fired for Unapproved Outside Business Activity, Transitions to New Firm
March 5th, 2021 at 1:33 PM
SEC Announces 2021 Examination Priorities
March 4th, 2021 at 2:29 PM
Read More »
Latest News
CFP Board is the New Sheriff and it Is Not Your Friend
October 24th, 2020 at 10:04 AM
Defending Against a Customer Complaint First Requires Selecting Correct Legal Counsel
October 15th, 2020 at 10:02 AM
Read More »
Share

Request a Free Consultation

Attorneys are standing by during regular business hours. Call us now for immediate service, or complete the form below and we will contact you as soon as possible.

Your E-mail Address:
 
Chicago
55 West Monroe St.
Suite 610
Chicago, Illinois 60603
(312) 332-0000
(312) 332-0003
New York City
One Liberty Plaza
165 Broadway, 23rd Floor
New York, New York 10006
(312) 332-0000
(312) 332-0003
Boca Raton
2255 Glades Road
Suite 324A
Boca Raton, Florida 33431
(312) 332-0000
(312) 332-0003
2021 © Eccleston Law, LLC.
All Rights Reserved.
The law is continuously changing. Please do not rely on information found on this site without consulting a lawyer to determine if any recent changes in the law may have an impact.