AXA Fined $20 Million for Variable Annuities Improprieties

Posted on March 28th, 2014 at 9:00 AM

From the Desk of Jim Eccleston at Eccleston Law Offices:

The New York Department of Financial Services (“NYDFS”) charged a $20 million fine to AXA Equitable Life Insurance Co. for limiting returns to legacy variable annuity clients without proper notice.

In 2009, 2010 and 2011, AXA added a “Tactical Manager Strategy”, which utilizes derivatives to lower volatility during rocky markets, for certain variable annuity contracts. 

Though NYDFS had approved AXA’s strategy at the time, the agency now alleges that the insurer failed to inform and explain to the department the significance of the changes brought about by introducing the Tactical Manager Strategy to existing policyholders.

According to NYDFS, the potential risks of the strategy include: limiting gains that a client would otherwise receive; and loweringthe value of certain guaranteed benefits that are eligible for periodic benefit base resets, so that the client is eligible only for a benefit base reset when his or her account value rises.

The change effectively altered the nature of the product which AXA did not explain to NYDFS. 

On a related note, the SEC has signaled that it is keeping a close eye on product filings and updates to existing variable annuity contracts which could potentially curb investors’ returns or impede their ability to build their benefit base by keeping them from contributing more money to the contract. Further, FINRA has indicated that advisers still are on the hook for continuing suitability determinations with respect to old variable annuity contracts that undergo updates and changes.

The attorneys of Eccleston Law Offices represent investors and advisers nationwide in securities and employment matters. Our attorneys draw on a combined experience of nearly 50 years in delivering the highest quality legal services.

Related Attorneys: James J. Eccleston


Return to Archive



I learned two important things working with Eccleston Law. First, I made a friend and ally with Jim and Steph for life. Secondly, and this is a crucial life lesson - if you need counsel, then seek out the very best. Jim was referred to me by a most trusted source. I've never had to hire an attorney for anything. Now, I know the value of hiring an important partner. Meticulous, thorough and detailed in preparation is the best way to describe Jim. Brilliant too, I might add. Bottom line, I would highly highly recommend Jim and Stephany for your legal needs. One of the best life decisions I've ever made.

Howard S.


January 25, 2022
Top FINRA Initiatives For 2022

A host of new initiatives are ahead in 2022 at the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), according to CEO Robert Cook.

January 24, 2022
FINRA Set To Issue Crypto Notice And Consider Expungement Reform

The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) is set to issue a regulatory notice pertaining to cryptocurrency as well as expungement reform.

January 21, 2022
CFP Board Establishes New Appeals Commission

The Certified Financial Planner (CFP) Board of Standards has established a new Appeals Commission. As the name suggests, the Appeals Commission possesses the sole authority to adjudicate appeal hearings.