Arbitration Panel Orders Morgan Stanley to Pay $843,000 for Failing to Protect Elderly Client from Fraud

Posted on February 27th, 2025 at 2:35 PM
Arbitration Panel Orders Morgan Stanley to Pay $843,000 for Failing to Protect Elderly Client from Fraud

From the desk of Jim Eccleston at Eccleston Law

A FINRA arbitration panel has ordered Morgan Stanley to pay $843,000 in compensatory damages to a senior client residing in Florida for failing to protect her from financial fraud. As reported by ThinkAdvisor, the panel found the firm liable for negligence in a case that highlighted the growing risk of elder financial exploitation.

The client alleged that Morgan Stanley breached its fiduciary duty and duties of care owed to a senior investor by not intervening when scammers manipulated her into withdrawing significant funds.

According to the claim, scammers posing as government officials convinced the client that her identity had been used in criminal activity and that her assets would be frozen unless she took immediate action. Over nine days in 2023, she withdrew more than $2 million, including liquidating assets from a life insurance trust and drawing from a line of credit. The scammers, who had access to her account, instructed her to convert funds into gold bars and cryptocurrency. They later collected the gold bars from her residence under the guise of transferring them to a secure government escrow account.

Despite apparent red flags, the client’s Morgan Stanley advisor approved and facilitated the transactions. Her claim highlighted the firm’s failure to recognize clear warning signs of financial exploitation, particularly given the sudden and unusual nature of the withdrawals.

According to ThinkAdvisor, Morgan Stanley denied liability, arguing that the fraud occurred outside the firm and that Kessler misrepresented the purpose of the transfers. Nonetheless, the arbitrators found Morgan Stanley liable and in violation of two FINRA rules designed to safeguard senior investors from fraud schemes.

 

Eccleston Law LLC represents investors and financial advisors nationwide in securities, employment, transition, regulatory, and disciplinary matters.

Tags: eccleston, eccleston law, morgan stanley

Return to Archive

TESTIMONIALS

Previous
Next

I learned two important things working with Eccleston Law. First, I made a friend and ally with Jim and Steph for life. Secondly, and this is a crucial life lesson - if you need counsel, then seek out the very best. Jim was referred to me by a most trusted source. I've never had to hire an attorney for anything. Now, I know the value of hiring an important partner. Meticulous, thorough and detailed in preparation is the best way to describe Jim. Brilliant too, I might add. Bottom line, I would highly highly recommend Jim and Stephany for your legal needs. One of the best life decisions I've ever made.

Howard S.

LATEST NEWS AND ARTICLES

January 30, 2026
FINRA Arbitration Panel Orders J.P. Morgan to Amend Form U-5, Flags Potential Pattern of Conduct

A Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) arbitration panel recently issued an unusually detailed decision in a dispute between J.P. Morgan Securities and former advisor Joshua David Sappi Biering, shedding rare light on how a firm may deploy - and sometimes abuse - the Form U-5 during advisor departures.

January 29, 2026
OFAC Targets Individual Trustee, Sending a Clear Warning to Fiduciaries and Family Offices

In a rare move, the Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) penalized a former U.S. government official, underscoring that professional gatekeepers can face personal liability for sanctions violations tied to trust administration.

January 28, 2026
FINRA Advances Overhaul of Outside Business Activity Rules to the SEC

FINRA formally has advanced its proposed overhaul of outside business activity (OBA) regulations to the Securities and Exchange Commission.